New York Times Investigative Reporter and Pulitzer Prize winner Nikole Hannah Jones shocked the world of higher education when she accepted a tenured position at Howard University over her beloved alma mater, The University of North Carolina, earlier this year.
After going through the tenure process and receiving unanimous approval from the faculty, Jones’s initial tenure request was denied by UNC’s board of trustees. Months later, amid mounting pressure, UNC voted to offer Hannah Jones tenure after all.
She replied, “To be denied it to only have that vote occur on the last possible day, at the last possible moment, after threat of legal action, after weeks of protest, after it became a national scandal, it’s just not something I want anymore.”
She instead decided to accept a tenure offer from Howard University, one of the most renowned historically black colleges in the nation.
“I really wanted to take my talents and the resources I could bring and bring them to an institution that was actually built for Black uplift and Black excellence, that wasn’t built in opposition to the work that I want to do and me as a human being.” she said.
I talked to famed writer of The Root.com Michael Harriot and 3rd year UCLA Law student Latrel Powell on what this decision means to the future of higher education, especially historically black colleges and universities.
“I thought it was almost a fairytale ending” Harriot said. “That’s a position that black people are often in where we are disrespected but we’re not in control of these institutions that control our livelihood.” Harriot continued, “I think this was the best possible outcome and for her to have what most people would consider a better outcome at Howard University.”
When asked why he thought Hannah Jones was denied tenure in the first place, Harriot noted Jones’ work on The 1619 Project and critical race theory.
“A big donor to the Journalism school at UNC is a right-wing guy who probably disagrees with the idea of The 1619 Project.”
-Michael harriot
Powell, a fan favorite here on Erupt, added, “In America we’ve seen this evolution with racism & white supremacy where a black person’s acceptance or presence in this space subverts so many power dynamics that have evolved and been maintained for centuries in this country. That’s what The 1619 Project is all about.”
We also discussed demographics and the lack of diversity among higher education faculty. Many universities say they have made progress in diversifying their faculty but that the process is slow because the pool of Black & Latino Ph.D. candidates is smaller than that of white candidates.
Harriot, however, believes that universities “whittle away from the pool at the beginning.” He argues that black students are “scrutinized harder throughout the PhD candidate process, and then they make it hard to get a job at a university, and then they make it hard to get tenure. So, when it’s time for that tenure process, they can say, ‘Oh, it’s just not a whole lot of black people here’, when a lot of times those connections and the advocates for people who are white, push them through the process. We don’t have that.”
Harriot continues, “And that’s what we mean by systemic racism. It’s not an intentional, malicious thing. It is the way that this world, this country, and these institutions are designed.”
Towards the end of our conversation, we discussed historically black colleges and universities (HBCU’s) and what role they might play in the future of black students and faculty.
“The only reason most black people wouldn’t be at HBCU’s is probably because of the way the system has funded them and regarded them. Black people know that the level of education is good. When you see black excellence in America, it is HBCU’s that are producing those things.” Harriot says, “Nikole Hannah Jones got a better job.”
Earlier this month UNC Journalism School Dean, Susan King, who led the effort to bring Hannah Jones to UNC’s Facutly, stepped down from her position. The move made no specific reference to this controversy.